Is this the end of shisha? New smoking laws may snuff out Middle Eastern water pipes in outdoor cafe

Bookmark this
February 03, 2015 By Jenny Pogson | Parramatta Advertiser

LAWS banning smoking in outdoor dining areas from July 6 may spell the end of Parramatta’s popular shisha restaurants.

Commercial outdoor dining areas in NSW will be smoke-free under the revised laws, with legislation applying to all ignited smoking products, including cigarettes, cigars, pipes and water pipes.

However, Mustafa Krich, owner of Parramatta’s Armani Restaurant in Church St, said the new laws would jeopardise his business and may force his staff out of work.

The restaurant has an al fresco tent where diners can eat and smoke water pipes, or argileh, in a Middle Eastern style setting.

Parramatta restaurant owner Mustafa Krich
Parramatta restaurant owner Mustafa Krich says new smoking bans in outdoor dining areas may force his business, which offers shisha smoking, to close.

“We’re very worried, we’ve got 40-50 staff and I don’t know if we’re going to have to close,” Mr Krich said.

“With cigarettes you can walk away and smoke for a quick two or three minutes, but with argileh you can’t walk away with it in your hand.”



Mr Krich wants the government to offer exemptions for premises that offer water pipes, also known as hookah and hubbly bubbly, to preserve the ancient cultural practice.

Armani was one of several restaurants involved in the Parramatta Business Freedom Association, which took Parramatta Council to the Land and Environment Court in 2012 after it tried to introduce a local ban on smoking in outdoor dining areas.

Mustafa Krich (left) and Sam Sakalaki 
Mustafa Krich (left) and Sam Sakalaki were part of the fight to retain water pipe smoking at Parramatta in 2012.

While the court found the council had the right to bring in the ban, the council overturned the decision and waited until the NSW Government’s blanket ban came into effect.

The lawyer who represented the restaurateurs, Benjamin Barrak, said there was no question that smoking was bad for health, but it was about freedom of choice.

“People can choose to do this and let the marketplace dictate how people operate,” Mr Barrak said. “Customers can choose to come to this restaurant or go to another restaurant that doesn’t have smoking.

“We’re not arguing that the law should not be imposed but there should be an exemption for this particular product.”

Mo Aldaour smoking his Argila in a cafe in Parramatta.
Mo Aldaour smoking his Argila in a cafe in Parramatta.

A spokeswoman for NSW Health said the government was not looking into special licenses or exemptions for premises that offered water pipes.

According to information provided by NSW Health smoke from a water-pipe, like all smoking products, endangers the health of smokers and of others exposed to it and the toxins are not filtered out by the water in the pipe.

NSW Health Director of the Centre for Population Health, Dr Jo Mitchell, said there was no safe level of exposure to second-hand tobacco smoke.

“There is strong public support for making outdoor dining areas smoke-free and a number of businesses have already voluntarily banned smoking in their outdoor dining areas, with positive results,” she said.



From July 6 under the Smoke-free Environment Act 2000 smoking will be banned in commercial outdoor dining areas, including:

● a seated dining area

● within four metres of a seated dining area on licensed premises, restaurant or cafe

● within 10 metres of a food fair stall

● within four metres of a pedestrian entry to or exit from a licensed premises or restaurant

Written by

Jenny Pogson | Parramatta Advertiser


Recent Articles

Bank of Beirut Internship

Bank of Beirut Internship

in Community News

CALLING ALL 3rd Year UNI STUDENTS; Work experience with the Bank of Beirut, Lebanon. This is initiated by the World Patriarchal Maronite Foundation for Integral Development and Bank of Beirut, in cooperation with Western Sydney University (WSU).

May 31, 2019

عودة لبنان الى قائمة الفاتيكان للحج الديني

عودة لبنان الى قائمة الفاتيكان للحج الديني

in World News, Local News, Church News

زار وفد من الوكالة الفاتيكانية للسياحة الدينية بيروت لدفع الترتيبات الخاصة بعودة الوكالة إلى لبنان وادراجه في لائحة دول السياحة الدينية بعد انقطاع امتد لسنوات

February 7, 2019 By AL-MOHAJER

Israeli Museum under Fire over 'McJesus' Exhibit

Israeli Museum under Fire over 'McJesus' Exhibit

in World News

A fast-food clown nailed to a cross has united its Finnish creator with Holy Land Christians demanding the artwork's removal from an exhibition at an Israeli museum.

January 15, 2019

Salameh: Money Transfer Firms Must Not Pay in Dollar to Recipients

Salameh: Money Transfer Firms Must Not Pay in Dollar to Recipients

in Local News

Central Bank Governor Riad Salameh on Monday called on all money transfer companies operating in Lebanon, such as Western Union and OMT, to exclusively use Lebanese currency when dispensing foreign cash transfers to recipients.

January 15, 2019